Skip to content

Compare

Outsourced accounting vs. hiring an in-house bookkeeper

The short answer

Outsourcing fits most small and mid-sized businesses that need accurate monthly books but not a full-time finance employee. With I&S you pay a flat monthly fee from $450, with accounting software and CPA review of bookkeeping transactions included. An in-house bookkeeper typically costs $4,000–$8,000 or more per month in salary before software, benefits, and review, and makes sense once you need someone on site every day.

Updated

Side by side

What is comparedI&SIn-house bookkeeper
Monthly costFlat fee, from $450$4k–$8k+ salary, plus benefits and payroll taxes
CPA review of transactionsIncluded in monthly bookkeepingExtra cost, usually an outside CPA
Accounting softwareIncluded (LedgerHub and McaHawk)You buy and maintain it
CoverageA team, so vacations and turnover don't stop the closeOne person's bandwidth
MCA / syndication experienceCore specialtyDepends on the hire
On-site, same-day tasksRemote; handled through the client portalYes, in your office

I&S is the better fit when

  • You want a predictable monthly cost instead of salary, benefits, and software subscriptions.
  • You want a licensed CPA reviewing bookkeeping transactions without paying for a separate engagement.
  • Your books need industry knowledge (MCA, construction, real estate, eCommerce) that is hard to hire for.
  • You have been burned by turnover and want the work to continue when one person leaves.

Another option is the better fit when

  • You need someone physically in the office every day for filing, mail, and walk-up requests.
  • Your transaction volume is high enough to fill a full-time role and you already have CPA oversight in place.
  • The role also covers duties outside accounting, such as office management or HR administration.

Common questions

Books you don't have to think about.

Get a free books review. We'll tell you honestly where things stand and give you a flat monthly quote — no pressure.

A Christmas tree with warm lights and gold and teal ornaments. A festive print surprise from I&S Accounting.

A little holiday cheer from I&S Accounting.

For our printable pricing guide: iandsaccountingsvcs.com/pricing